Philosophy
Kosovo's declaration of independence today raises a question. On the one hand, the idea of a group receiving the right to self-govern seems to be intrinsically good. Autonomy and self-determination are an important part of a full recognition of humanity. To be ruled over, especially if one is part of an oppressed minority or, in some cases, an oppressed majority, is to have personhood not fully appreciated. On such terms, independence of any gorup of people thereby appears to be something celebratory.
On the other hand, the meaning of independence is contextual. If we are talking about decolonization like we saw during much of the 20th century, that is one thing, but now, the independence movements we see in Europe with the Kosovar Albanian, Basque, and Kurd movements, the Tamils in Sri Lanka and the freee Aceh movement in Indonesia, the trouble Kenya and Sudan, just to name a few are often the result of multiethnic societies pulling apart at the seams. Instead of a people getting freedom from a foreign dictator, independence now is the result of our inability to maintain fair and just working governments that rule over different groups of people. The contemporary independence declarations are a sign of failure, the sad result of our inability to meaningfully embrace morality and equality, a lack of caring and imagination for the humanity of all. Unlike the decolonization process that followed the world wars, the independence of peoples is not a move towards a unifying the world, but a step in politically isolating ourselves from ourselves.
Kosovar independence leaves me unsure of my own feelings. On the one hand, it is wonderful to see a people free, on the other hand, we should worry about what it is that they have to free themselves from.
- What's The Difference: July 4th Edition
For an Independence Day edition of "What's the Difference?", what's the difference between national pride, patriotism, and nationalism?...
- Happy Independence Day
Happy independence day, everyone. To show that there's no hard feelings, here's a couple of thoughts relating to Great Britain. The first is truly a celebration of freedom. Alan Johnston, the BBC reporter who has done some of the best work in...
- The Meaning Of The Declaration Of Independence
Last week in America we got to celebrate the 4th of July. To many people, this is a nice excuse to have a day off, spend it with family or friends, eat some hot dogs, drink some beer and watch some awesome fireworks. Nothing wrong with that. It is important...
- Restoration Of 'star Spangled Banner' Uncovers Horrifying New Verses
As we prepare to get patriotic this weekend to celebrate another anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, it may also be worth reflecting on the history of the Star Spangled Banner. When I was younger, I must confess I always assumed the song started...
- Thomas Jefferson's "faux Pas"
"Hyperspectral Analysis Reveals Foundation of American Philosophy" by Darleen Hartley July 12th, 2010 BRIGHT SIDE OF NEWS LED-based analysis is shining a light beneath the final layer of ink on a revered United States document. It revealed how Thomas...
Philosophy
Independence and Multiethnicity
Kosovo's declaration of independence today raises a question. On the one hand, the idea of a group receiving the right to self-govern seems to be intrinsically good. Autonomy and self-determination are an important part of a full recognition of humanity. To be ruled over, especially if one is part of an oppressed minority or, in some cases, an oppressed majority, is to have personhood not fully appreciated. On such terms, independence of any gorup of people thereby appears to be something celebratory.
On the other hand, the meaning of independence is contextual. If we are talking about decolonization like we saw during much of the 20th century, that is one thing, but now, the independence movements we see in Europe with the Kosovar Albanian, Basque, and Kurd movements, the Tamils in Sri Lanka and the freee Aceh movement in Indonesia, the trouble Kenya and Sudan, just to name a few are often the result of multiethnic societies pulling apart at the seams. Instead of a people getting freedom from a foreign dictator, independence now is the result of our inability to maintain fair and just working governments that rule over different groups of people. The contemporary independence declarations are a sign of failure, the sad result of our inability to meaningfully embrace morality and equality, a lack of caring and imagination for the humanity of all. Unlike the decolonization process that followed the world wars, the independence of peoples is not a move towards a unifying the world, but a step in politically isolating ourselves from ourselves.
Kosovar independence leaves me unsure of my own feelings. On the one hand, it is wonderful to see a people free, on the other hand, we should worry about what it is that they have to free themselves from.
- What's The Difference: July 4th Edition
For an Independence Day edition of "What's the Difference?", what's the difference between national pride, patriotism, and nationalism?...
- Happy Independence Day
Happy independence day, everyone. To show that there's no hard feelings, here's a couple of thoughts relating to Great Britain. The first is truly a celebration of freedom. Alan Johnston, the BBC reporter who has done some of the best work in...
- The Meaning Of The Declaration Of Independence
Last week in America we got to celebrate the 4th of July. To many people, this is a nice excuse to have a day off, spend it with family or friends, eat some hot dogs, drink some beer and watch some awesome fireworks. Nothing wrong with that. It is important...
- Restoration Of 'star Spangled Banner' Uncovers Horrifying New Verses
As we prepare to get patriotic this weekend to celebrate another anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, it may also be worth reflecting on the history of the Star Spangled Banner. When I was younger, I must confess I always assumed the song started...
- Thomas Jefferson's "faux Pas"
"Hyperspectral Analysis Reveals Foundation of American Philosophy" by Darleen Hartley July 12th, 2010 BRIGHT SIDE OF NEWS LED-based analysis is shining a light beneath the final layer of ink on a revered United States document. It revealed how Thomas...