Philosophy
"Fuel leak" was what is was called this time...the time before was a fractured fuel valve. Shuttle Discovery has made 35 previous trips and despite retrofitting of the craft, it is getting fatigued and old. It has outlived its function. Fortunately the issues was found while all was on the ground. These are small but significant issues that could abort or totally jeopardize a mission. These missions are but a few hundred miles away but consider a small issue thousands or millions of miles away--then what. It just shows that the mechanicals of any system can fail and cause problems. Best to stay put and let probes, satellites, and unmanned vehicles do the work and take the risks...and done cheaper.
KENNEDY SPACE CENTER, Fla. — The space shuttle Discovery will remain on the ground until at least Sunday after a hydrogen leak scrubbed a launch attempt on Wednesday.
"We're in the business of launching, not scrubbing," said Michael D. Leinbach, the shuttle launch director at a news conference Wednesday evening. "But our business requires perfection, and our vehicle was not perfect today."
Technicians will not be able to get a close look at the leak site, near the connection of a vent line to the external fuel tank, until Friday afternoon. The vent line carries away excess hydrogen pressure from the tank and the spacecraft to where it is safely burned.
If the fix is straightforward and quick, shuttle officials hope to launch the Discovery at 7:43 p.m. Sunday.
That will put a time crunch on the mission, because the Discovery has to undock to make room for the arrival of a Russian Soyuz spacecraft, scheduled to launch the next day.
If the Discovery launches Sunday, the mission would be shortened from 14 days to 12 days and one of the planned four spacewalks would be eliminated. If the launch is pushed back to Monday or Tuesday, then the mission would be further shortened with time for probably only one spacewalk.
But that would still accomplish the main objectives of the mission: to deliver the last segment of the space station's backbone truss, a replacement part for a water recycling system and Koichi Wakata, who will join the crew of the space station.
If the Discovery cannot launch by Tuesday, then the mission will likely be pushed to April, with repercussions on the schedule of future shuttle missions and the construction of the space station.
The countdown was proceeding smoothly toward a 9:20 p.m. liftoff under clear skies and full moon. But at about 2 p.m., when the hydrogen tank reached 98 percent full, sensors detected a hydrogen leak at the valve next to the external tank, creating a potential flammability problem. The launch was called off at 2:36 p.m.
Mr. Leinbach said he was 99.9 percent certain that the leak was in the ground equipment and in the shuttle itself, which would make it easier to fix.
"We'll replace what needs fixing," Mr Leinbach said. "We have spares on the shelf."
NASA officials said the leak was not related to three hydrogen gas valves that were inspected after a similar valve broke during the mission of the shuttle Endeavour in November. That failure had no effect on Endeavour’s ascent into orbit, but it did lead to concerns that if a larger piece broke off it could be catastrophic.
NASA postponed the launching of Discovery several times to analyze the valves, and the mission is now a month behind its original launching date.
Through experiments and computer simulations, NASA engineers concluded that it was highly unlikely that a piece from a valve would cause significant damage, and a new magnetic testing method convinced them that the three valves installed in the Discovery were free of cracks.
The Discovery's main cargo is a 45-foot-long, 31,000-pound truss segment with two sets of solar panels.
When the solar panels are unfurled and plugged in, the station’s power-generating capacity will rise to 120 kilowatts from 90 kilowatts.
Also aboard Discovery is a 180-pound replacement part for a water recycling system that the Endeavour took to the space station in November. But a key part in the apparatus that transforms urine into drinkable water failed almost immediately. NASA would like the recycling system fully functional before the expansion of the station of the station crew from three to six, planned for late May.
Changing horizon of space exploration participants
Colonization or contamination?
Deceased--Ernst Stuhlinger
Deceased--Konrad Dannenberg
Deceased--Thomas F. Rogers
In remembrance...our space travelers
ISS--"dump or keep" poll
"Manned space travel" poll
Space ethics
Space exploration?...Stephen Hawking's perspective
Sex in space--amusing but a problem
Sex in space--redux
Sex in space taken seriously
Space tourism?
Space travel...real issues
Value of space exploration?
Von Braun sketches for sale
- Shuttle Discovery--the End
Suitable for printing and framing. "Ode to Discovery: Space shuttle ends a successful mission, career" Space shuttle Discovery taxied to a stop at Kennedy Space Center just before noon Wednesday, ending a triumphant 13-day mission and 27-year career....
- Fuel Leak On Space Shuttle Discovery
Again a mechanical problem has delayed the shuttle and cost more millions. "Space shuttle launch postponed again" by Irene Klotz August 25th, 2009 Reuters NASA delayed a Wednesday morning liftoff of the space shuttle Discovery because of an apparent...
- Endeavour Is Struck By Debris
Endeavour July 15th, 2009 Still more evidence of the perils of man in space...need I say more. Serious or not...the whole program needs to be reevaluated. "Debris Strikes Endeavour During Liftoff" by Kenneth Chang July 16th, 2009 The New York Times ...
- 1 In 318...odds Are Not Good
"NASA: Shuttle's Risk of Debris Strike Up 6 Percent" by Clara Moskowitz March 6th, 2009 space.com The recent surge in space junk created by an accidental satellite collision last month has bumped up the upcoming space shuttle mission's chances...
- "manned Space Travel" Poll
"Given the expense, complexity, and uncertainty of mankind traveling in space, should such enterprises be suspended and greater relevance be placed on unmanned instruments to garner data and knowledge." I am a bit surprised by the results...4 [50%]...
Philosophy
Good reason to keep feet on the ground
"Fuel leak" was what is was called this time...the time before was a fractured fuel valve. Shuttle Discovery has made 35 previous trips and despite retrofitting of the craft, it is getting fatigued and old. It has outlived its function. Fortunately the issues was found while all was on the ground. These are small but significant issues that could abort or totally jeopardize a mission. These missions are but a few hundred miles away but consider a small issue thousands or millions of miles away--then what. It just shows that the mechanicals of any system can fail and cause problems. Best to stay put and let probes, satellites, and unmanned vehicles do the work and take the risks...and done cheaper.
"Launching of Shuttle Postponed Again"
by
Kenneth Chang
March 12th, 2009
The New York Times
by
Kenneth Chang
March 12th, 2009
The New York Times
KENNEDY SPACE CENTER, Fla. — The space shuttle Discovery will remain on the ground until at least Sunday after a hydrogen leak scrubbed a launch attempt on Wednesday.
"We're in the business of launching, not scrubbing," said Michael D. Leinbach, the shuttle launch director at a news conference Wednesday evening. "But our business requires perfection, and our vehicle was not perfect today."
Technicians will not be able to get a close look at the leak site, near the connection of a vent line to the external fuel tank, until Friday afternoon. The vent line carries away excess hydrogen pressure from the tank and the spacecraft to where it is safely burned.
If the fix is straightforward and quick, shuttle officials hope to launch the Discovery at 7:43 p.m. Sunday.
That will put a time crunch on the mission, because the Discovery has to undock to make room for the arrival of a Russian Soyuz spacecraft, scheduled to launch the next day.
If the Discovery launches Sunday, the mission would be shortened from 14 days to 12 days and one of the planned four spacewalks would be eliminated. If the launch is pushed back to Monday or Tuesday, then the mission would be further shortened with time for probably only one spacewalk.
But that would still accomplish the main objectives of the mission: to deliver the last segment of the space station's backbone truss, a replacement part for a water recycling system and Koichi Wakata, who will join the crew of the space station.
If the Discovery cannot launch by Tuesday, then the mission will likely be pushed to April, with repercussions on the schedule of future shuttle missions and the construction of the space station.
The countdown was proceeding smoothly toward a 9:20 p.m. liftoff under clear skies and full moon. But at about 2 p.m., when the hydrogen tank reached 98 percent full, sensors detected a hydrogen leak at the valve next to the external tank, creating a potential flammability problem. The launch was called off at 2:36 p.m.
Mr. Leinbach said he was 99.9 percent certain that the leak was in the ground equipment and in the shuttle itself, which would make it easier to fix.
"We'll replace what needs fixing," Mr Leinbach said. "We have spares on the shelf."
NASA officials said the leak was not related to three hydrogen gas valves that were inspected after a similar valve broke during the mission of the shuttle Endeavour in November. That failure had no effect on Endeavour’s ascent into orbit, but it did lead to concerns that if a larger piece broke off it could be catastrophic.
NASA postponed the launching of Discovery several times to analyze the valves, and the mission is now a month behind its original launching date.
Through experiments and computer simulations, NASA engineers concluded that it was highly unlikely that a piece from a valve would cause significant damage, and a new magnetic testing method convinced them that the three valves installed in the Discovery were free of cracks.
The Discovery's main cargo is a 45-foot-long, 31,000-pound truss segment with two sets of solar panels.
When the solar panels are unfurled and plugged in, the station’s power-generating capacity will rise to 120 kilowatts from 90 kilowatts.
Also aboard Discovery is a 180-pound replacement part for a water recycling system that the Endeavour took to the space station in November. But a key part in the apparatus that transforms urine into drinkable water failed almost immediately. NASA would like the recycling system fully functional before the expansion of the station of the station crew from three to six, planned for late May.
Changing horizon of space exploration participants
Colonization or contamination?
Deceased--Ernst Stuhlinger
Deceased--Konrad Dannenberg
Deceased--Thomas F. Rogers
In remembrance...our space travelers
ISS--"dump or keep" poll
"Manned space travel" poll
Space ethics
Space exploration?...Stephen Hawking's perspective
Sex in space--amusing but a problem
Sex in space--redux
Sex in space taken seriously
Space tourism?
Space travel...real issues
Value of space exploration?
Von Braun sketches for sale
- Shuttle Discovery--the End
Suitable for printing and framing. "Ode to Discovery: Space shuttle ends a successful mission, career" Space shuttle Discovery taxied to a stop at Kennedy Space Center just before noon Wednesday, ending a triumphant 13-day mission and 27-year career....
- Fuel Leak On Space Shuttle Discovery
Again a mechanical problem has delayed the shuttle and cost more millions. "Space shuttle launch postponed again" by Irene Klotz August 25th, 2009 Reuters NASA delayed a Wednesday morning liftoff of the space shuttle Discovery because of an apparent...
- Endeavour Is Struck By Debris
Endeavour July 15th, 2009 Still more evidence of the perils of man in space...need I say more. Serious or not...the whole program needs to be reevaluated. "Debris Strikes Endeavour During Liftoff" by Kenneth Chang July 16th, 2009 The New York Times ...
- 1 In 318...odds Are Not Good
"NASA: Shuttle's Risk of Debris Strike Up 6 Percent" by Clara Moskowitz March 6th, 2009 space.com The recent surge in space junk created by an accidental satellite collision last month has bumped up the upcoming space shuttle mission's chances...
- "manned Space Travel" Poll
"Given the expense, complexity, and uncertainty of mankind traveling in space, should such enterprises be suspended and greater relevance be placed on unmanned instruments to garner data and knowledge." I am a bit surprised by the results...4 [50%]...