Philosophy
Guest-post from C.Ewing today:
Assuming that we use the simple "a painter is one who paints" definition, which seems passably insufficient, we have to also understand (in order to both comprehend and utilize the term properly) what it means to be "one who paints". One obvious explanation is that you are a painter when you are painting. But this is not consistent with usage at all. When a painter stops painting for the day the painter does not lose the tag painter, and suddenly regain it at a later time when painting is resumed. So that doesn't work for us.
Perhaps, we can say one who paints habitually. It's thus a profession or at least a hobby. But that gets us quickly onto a sliding scale. Just how habitually must the habitual be done in order for it to be habitually done? Once a day? Once a week? Once a month?
What if a person gives up the profession? We could say, "X is a retired painter". But this may indicate that X no longer paints, much in the way a retired factory worker no longer works in a factory. We could also say, "Y used to be a painter but doesn't do it so much anymore". This indicates that the person is no longer a painter due to infrequency, although the action is still performed. But if this seems insufficient I think it's because it is teetering towards another usage, and perhaps therein lies the problem. Painter doesn't just indicate the activity, but rather an identity-quality that we associate with a given person.
If a given person stops selling paintings, and thus retires from the market, we might still call the person a painter if the work is still done. Not a professional, obviously, because the profession has been discarded, but still a painter. But if the person stops altogether, does the painter-identifier linger? It seems like in some cases it might. People are often identified by not only what they do, but what they have done, especially if it endured over many years and/or the person was particularly acknowledged for it.
I'm not sure how to properly divide the terminology from the identity question here. It seems like how we identify the person largely determines how we use the term, and indeed, what the term actually means in a given case.
So, I guess my question remains: does a painter paint?
- What Is Sexual Orientation?
The George Rekers situation is good for more than just snark. His hiring of a male prostitute for massage purposes with no intercourse was meant to satisfy his urges while granting him plausible deniability that he is gay, after all, he would argue, he...
- Something From Camus
The Life of the Artist: A Mimodrama in Two Parts by Albert Camus Translated by Ryan Bloom First published in February 1953 PART ONE A. A small painter’s studio. Three walls, one of which is, perhaps, made of glass. These panels must be mobile. The...
- Ancient Egyptian Humor
David Roberts October 24th, 1796 to November 25th, 1864 Roberts was a Scottish painter and was especially known for a prolific series of detailed prints of Egypt and the Near East produced during the 1840s from sketches made during long tours of...
- Deceased--cy Twombly
Cy Twombly April 25th, 1928 to July 5th, 2011 "American painter Cy Twombly, celebrated for large-scale scribble paintings, dies in Rome at 83" July 5th, 2011 Associated Press Celebrated American painter Cy Twombly, whose large-scale paintings featuring...
- "art" Poll
The Painter's Honeymoon Fredric Leighton Do you participate in any art media [painting, photography, woodworking, etc.]? No...1 Yes...5 Looks like most of us are involved in the arts...that is good. Hobbies are very productive and therapeutic. Most...
Philosophy
Does a Painter Paint?
Guest-post from C.Ewing today:
Assuming that we use the simple "a painter is one who paints" definition, which seems passably insufficient, we have to also understand (in order to both comprehend and utilize the term properly) what it means to be "one who paints". One obvious explanation is that you are a painter when you are painting. But this is not consistent with usage at all. When a painter stops painting for the day the painter does not lose the tag painter, and suddenly regain it at a later time when painting is resumed. So that doesn't work for us.
Perhaps, we can say one who paints habitually. It's thus a profession or at least a hobby. But that gets us quickly onto a sliding scale. Just how habitually must the habitual be done in order for it to be habitually done? Once a day? Once a week? Once a month?
What if a person gives up the profession? We could say, "X is a retired painter". But this may indicate that X no longer paints, much in the way a retired factory worker no longer works in a factory. We could also say, "Y used to be a painter but
If a given person stops selling paintings, and thus retires from the market, we might still call the person a painter if the work is still done. Not a professional, obviously, because the profession has been discarded, but still a painter. But if the person stops altogether, does the painter-identifier linger? It seems like in some cases it might. People are often identified by not only what they do, but what they have done, especially if it endured over many years and/or the person was particularly acknowledged for it.
I'm not sure how to properly divide the terminology from the identity question here. It seems like how we identify the person largely determines how we use the term, and indeed, what the term actually means in a given case.
So, I guess my question remains: does a painter paint?
- What Is Sexual Orientation?
The George Rekers situation is good for more than just snark. His hiring of a male prostitute for massage purposes with no intercourse was meant to satisfy his urges while granting him plausible deniability that he is gay, after all, he would argue, he...
- Something From Camus
The Life of the Artist: A Mimodrama in Two Parts by Albert Camus Translated by Ryan Bloom First published in February 1953 PART ONE A. A small painter’s studio. Three walls, one of which is, perhaps, made of glass. These panels must be mobile. The...
- Ancient Egyptian Humor
David Roberts October 24th, 1796 to November 25th, 1864 Roberts was a Scottish painter and was especially known for a prolific series of detailed prints of Egypt and the Near East produced during the 1840s from sketches made during long tours of...
- Deceased--cy Twombly
Cy Twombly April 25th, 1928 to July 5th, 2011 "American painter Cy Twombly, celebrated for large-scale scribble paintings, dies in Rome at 83" July 5th, 2011 Associated Press Celebrated American painter Cy Twombly, whose large-scale paintings featuring...
- "art" Poll
The Painter's Honeymoon Fredric Leighton Do you participate in any art media [painting, photography, woodworking, etc.]? No...1 Yes...5 Looks like most of us are involved in the arts...that is good. Hobbies are very productive and therapeutic. Most...