Philosophy
Extinction of the dinosaurs is blamed on an asteroid impacting Chicxulub in the Gulf of Mexico...so says a blue ribbon panel of experts. I don't buy it for other factors are suspect too...climate, diet, size of the creatures, biological. Be careful of a single causal event.
It's official: The extinction of the dinosaurs and a host of other species 65.5 million years ago was caused by a massive asteroid that crashed into the Gulf of Mexico, creating worldwide havoc, an international team of researchers said Thursday.
The 7.5-mile-wide asteroid was traveling at a speed about 10 times that of a rifle bullet when it hit, releasing a billion times more energy than the Hiroshima atom bomb. The impact blew dirt and rock around the world, set massive wildfires, knocked down forests worldwide, triggered massive tsunamis and earthquakes of magnitude 11 or larger and even caused parts of the continent to slip into the ocean.
Those events wiped out more than half of all species on Earth in what has been called the greatest extinction event of all time. The species lost included not only the dinosaurs, but also the bird-like pterosaurs, large marine reptiles and many smaller land and sea creatures, clearing the way for the emergence of mammals as the dominant life form on the planet.
All of this may sound familiar. In fact, the idea was proposed 30 years ago by Nobel laureate physicist Luis Alvarez and his son Walter after they found abnormally high concentrations of the element iridium in sediments from what was then known as the K-T boundary. This 65.5-million-year old layer of Earth separates fossils of the Cretaceous period from those of the Tertiary period.
Iridium is rare on Earth, but common in space, and the Alvarezes proposed that a giant asteroid had hit the Earth, producing the sudden decline in species diversity previously observed at the K-T boundary -- which is how the boundary got its name in the first place.
Then, in 1991, researchers discovered a 120-mile wide, 1.5-mile deep crater called Chicxulub in Mexico with the same age as the K-T boundary. Most considered it the smoking gun for the extinction.
In recent years, however, some scientists have speculated about alternative causes for the extinction, arguing that it could have resulted from multiple asteroid impacts or, more likely, massive volcanic eruptions at the Deccan Traps in India.
To settle the question, European researchers decided to assemble what Kirk R. Johnson of the Denver Museum of Nature and Science called "a K-T boundary dream team," a collection of 45 internationally renowned scientists in a broad spectrum of disciplines to analyze the possible causes of the extinctions. Funding came from the National Science Foundation in the United States and from similar groups in other countries.Their conclusions will be published Friday in the journal Science.
"The answer is quite simple," Johnson, a co-author and spokesman for the group, said in a telephone news conference. "The crater really is the culprit."
The aftereffects from the impact "shrouded the planet in darkness and caused a global winter, killing off many species that couldn't adapt to the hellish environment," co-author and Earth scientist Joanna Morgan of Imperial College London said in a statement.
Proponents of a multiple-impact theory have cited the fact that there appear to be several distinct layers of comet debris near the Chicxulub crater and evidence for many species surviving after the impact, only to go extinct later. But the research team concluded that those anomalies were created by jumbling of strata when debris flowed back into the crater after the impact.
There are now more than 350 sites around the globe where researchers have studied the K-T boundary -- now officially called the Cretaceous-Paleogene, or K-Pg, boundary. (K is the traditional abbreviation for the Cretaceous.) The sites that are distant from Chicxulub show evidence of only one impact.
Timing is the problem with the Deccan traps. A variety of data show that there were three major pulses of volcanic activity, one about 400,000 years before the K-Pg boundary, one about 200,000 years after and one sometime in the middle.
If the volcanism were the cause of the extinction, "we would expect to see events in the biological world associated with it, but we don't," Johnson said. In fact, the first pulse of volcanism was associated with a slight global warming and an increase in biological diversity.
Moreover, the amount of sulfur injected into the atmosphere by the volcanoes -- assumed to be the cause of their global effects -- was actually many factors of 10 smaller than that ejected in the impact.
And what does it matter? "There are a lot of asteroids out there now," Johnson said, and it is important to know what would happen if one were to strike the Earth.
Does this remind anyone of the Pluto debate?
- Mounting Evidence On Dinosaur Extinction
An adult triceratops. "'Last dinosaur' fossil adds weight to theory asteroid wiped out creatures" Horn thought to be of a triceratops found in sedimentary rock was deposited shortly before mass extinction 65.5m years ago by Ian Sample July 13th,...
- Babylon's Nineveh, Austen Henry Layard, Asteroid
Austen Henry Layard March 5th, 1817 to July 5th, 1894 In 3123 BC, a Sumerian astronomer saw a devastating asteroid, perhaps a half-mile wide, according to an interpretation of a clay tablet, made by researchers from Bristol University, reported in The...
- Dead Dinos
This is odd for such a bold statement, this is only the second article I have seen on the subject. I still think it does not represent the whole story of the dinosaur's demise. "30 Years Later, What Killed The Dinosaurs Is Revisited" March 8th,...
- Commerce And Biodiversity
International Year of Biodiversity Indeed, commerce and the exploitation of raw materials will trip the balance of a biodiversity policy towards the negative...and maybe hasten the demise of humans too. "Losing biodiversity - Human beings under threat"...
- Dinosaur Extinction--"the Great Chicxulub Debate"
Gerta Keller It is popular to believe that the extinction of the dinosaurs was the result of a catastrophic event roughly 65 million years ago [Cretaceous-Tertiary (KT) extinction]. One of the more controversial and documented hypotheses has been "The...
Philosophy
Chicxulub asteroid caused the demise of the dinosaurs
Extinction of the dinosaurs is blamed on an asteroid impacting Chicxulub in the Gulf of Mexico...so says a blue ribbon panel of experts. I don't buy it for other factors are suspect too...climate, diet, size of the creatures, biological. Be careful of a single causal event.
"Scientists settle on single-asteroid hit as culprit in dinosaurs' demise"
A 'dream team' of researchers concludes that the massive Gulf of Mexico impact 65.5 million years ago -- not volcanoes or multiple impacts -- indeed caused the greatest extinction event of all
by
Thomas H. Maugh II
March 4th, 2010
latimes.com
A 'dream team' of researchers concludes that the massive Gulf of Mexico impact 65.5 million years ago -- not volcanoes or multiple impacts -- indeed caused the greatest extinction event of all
by
Thomas H. Maugh II
March 4th, 2010
latimes.com
It's official: The extinction of the dinosaurs and a host of other species 65.5 million years ago was caused by a massive asteroid that crashed into the Gulf of Mexico, creating worldwide havoc, an international team of researchers said Thursday.
The 7.5-mile-wide asteroid was traveling at a speed about 10 times that of a rifle bullet when it hit, releasing a billion times more energy than the Hiroshima atom bomb. The impact blew dirt and rock around the world, set massive wildfires, knocked down forests worldwide, triggered massive tsunamis and earthquakes of magnitude 11 or larger and even caused parts of the continent to slip into the ocean.
Those events wiped out more than half of all species on Earth in what has been called the greatest extinction event of all time. The species lost included not only the dinosaurs, but also the bird-like pterosaurs, large marine reptiles and many smaller land and sea creatures, clearing the way for the emergence of mammals as the dominant life form on the planet.
All of this may sound familiar. In fact, the idea was proposed 30 years ago by Nobel laureate physicist Luis Alvarez and his son Walter after they found abnormally high concentrations of the element iridium in sediments from what was then known as the K-T boundary. This 65.5-million-year old layer of Earth separates fossils of the Cretaceous period from those of the Tertiary period.
Iridium is rare on Earth, but common in space, and the Alvarezes proposed that a giant asteroid had hit the Earth, producing the sudden decline in species diversity previously observed at the K-T boundary -- which is how the boundary got its name in the first place.
Then, in 1991, researchers discovered a 120-mile wide, 1.5-mile deep crater called Chicxulub in Mexico with the same age as the K-T boundary. Most considered it the smoking gun for the extinction.
In recent years, however, some scientists have speculated about alternative causes for the extinction, arguing that it could have resulted from multiple asteroid impacts or, more likely, massive volcanic eruptions at the Deccan Traps in India.
To settle the question, European researchers decided to assemble what Kirk R. Johnson of the Denver Museum of Nature and Science called "a K-T boundary dream team," a collection of 45 internationally renowned scientists in a broad spectrum of disciplines to analyze the possible causes of the extinctions. Funding came from the National Science Foundation in the United States and from similar groups in other countries.Their conclusions will be published Friday in the journal Science.
"The answer is quite simple," Johnson, a co-author and spokesman for the group, said in a telephone news conference. "The crater really is the culprit."
The aftereffects from the impact "shrouded the planet in darkness and caused a global winter, killing off many species that couldn't adapt to the hellish environment," co-author and Earth scientist Joanna Morgan of Imperial College London said in a statement.
Proponents of a multiple-impact theory have cited the fact that there appear to be several distinct layers of comet debris near the Chicxulub crater and evidence for many species surviving after the impact, only to go extinct later. But the research team concluded that those anomalies were created by jumbling of strata when debris flowed back into the crater after the impact.
There are now more than 350 sites around the globe where researchers have studied the K-T boundary -- now officially called the Cretaceous-Paleogene, or K-Pg, boundary. (K is the traditional abbreviation for the Cretaceous.) The sites that are distant from Chicxulub show evidence of only one impact.
Timing is the problem with the Deccan traps. A variety of data show that there were three major pulses of volcanic activity, one about 400,000 years before the K-Pg boundary, one about 200,000 years after and one sometime in the middle.
If the volcanism were the cause of the extinction, "we would expect to see events in the biological world associated with it, but we don't," Johnson said. In fact, the first pulse of volcanism was associated with a slight global warming and an increase in biological diversity.
Moreover, the amount of sulfur injected into the atmosphere by the volcanoes -- assumed to be the cause of their global effects -- was actually many factors of 10 smaller than that ejected in the impact.
And what does it matter? "There are a lot of asteroids out there now," Johnson said, and it is important to know what would happen if one were to strike the Earth.
Does this remind anyone of the Pluto debate?
- Mounting Evidence On Dinosaur Extinction
An adult triceratops. "'Last dinosaur' fossil adds weight to theory asteroid wiped out creatures" Horn thought to be of a triceratops found in sedimentary rock was deposited shortly before mass extinction 65.5m years ago by Ian Sample July 13th,...
- Babylon's Nineveh, Austen Henry Layard, Asteroid
Austen Henry Layard March 5th, 1817 to July 5th, 1894 In 3123 BC, a Sumerian astronomer saw a devastating asteroid, perhaps a half-mile wide, according to an interpretation of a clay tablet, made by researchers from Bristol University, reported in The...
- Dead Dinos
This is odd for such a bold statement, this is only the second article I have seen on the subject. I still think it does not represent the whole story of the dinosaur's demise. "30 Years Later, What Killed The Dinosaurs Is Revisited" March 8th,...
- Commerce And Biodiversity
International Year of Biodiversity Indeed, commerce and the exploitation of raw materials will trip the balance of a biodiversity policy towards the negative...and maybe hasten the demise of humans too. "Losing biodiversity - Human beings under threat"...
- Dinosaur Extinction--"the Great Chicxulub Debate"
Gerta Keller It is popular to believe that the extinction of the dinosaurs was the result of a catastrophic event roughly 65 million years ago [Cretaceous-Tertiary (KT) extinction]. One of the more controversial and documented hypotheses has been "The...